Home Blog Andrew Yang Describes School for Too Many Children as "Daily Low Grade...

Andrew Yang Describes School for Too Many Children as “Daily Low Grade Psychic Beatings.”

Education voters—people for whom education is the issue that determines their vote— have been banging our heads against the wall forever during presidential campaigns. Sure, the average American voter has included education in their list of the most important policy issues for decades. But despite America’s collective believe that education is a priority, very few voters actually vote on it and that has allowed presidential candidates to ignore it, pedal in popular and unworkable soundbites, or hold straight up terrible positions on the subject and get away with it. 

Andrew Yang is not peddling in soundbites or the ridiculous—in fact, he is the only candidate willing to say that he supports good schools regardless of what kind of school they are. It’s sad that his measured position is considered by some as controversial but fidelity to systems, however broken, has long overridden the needs of children in American politics.

Presidential candidate Andrew Yang was a guest on Eric Weinstein‘s podcast, The Portal. Eric Weinstein is a mathematical physicist, economist, and the managing director of Thiel Capital. During their conversation, they discussed a massively important education issue that no other candidate has touched, let alone talked about at length in the smart and honest way that these two men did. 

Weinstein raises the issue of demographic groups that emerge as voting blocks—he asserts that one important and totally ignored group consists of “parents of super smart kids who have some kind of a learning difference that causes them to wildly underperform in school.” 

Yang emphatically agrees. Weinstein admits he was that kid. Yang responds that he is that parent. Yang goes on to talk about how his son, who has autism, has tried various schooling environments and that the struggles during that process have been “sharp. 

Yang continues on to say that “our institutions aren’t well designed for people with different learning profiles or different approaches to the world.” And he acknowledges the luxury that both he and Weinstein enjoy in having the means—and therefore the freedom—to choose the best schools for their children.

Weinstein recollects his own time as a student—every conference was him listening to teachers tell his parents, “Eric is underperforming, Eric can’t meet his potential.” Weinstein goes on to say “you don’t realize how much damage you’re doing to maybe as much as ⅕ of the population.” Yang responds that he’s heard this very phenomenon described as “regular low grade psychic beatings.” 

Weinstein asserts that kids are sustaining more and more trauma every year and he describes the consequence as a “maddening loss of human brilliance.” He also employs the term “teaching disabilities” to describe the way in which we have utterly failed those who “don’t fit into the notion of what can be educated by one teacher teaching a room of 20 people to make the economics work.”

And then he uses the word “despair” to describe these parents that make up this not-so- hypothetical demographic:

”I want to talk to all of the parents who are leading lives of despair saying, ‘why is my kid wildly underperforming and I know how smart this kid is?’

Hallelujah (and thank you) is all I can say. It is high time a presidential candidate stop ignoring the parents and children who are being traumatized by the American school system. Despair is precisely what millions of parents—and children—feel. Andrew Yang is willing to say that our institutions, and specifically the public school system, aren’t well designed for a sizable portion of the population. 

Ok, Mr. Yang. The next question for you is what can we do about that?

What Do You Think?
Erika Sanzi
Erika Sanzi is a former educator and elected school committee member and the chief editor of this site, Project Forever Free. She is also a senior visiting fellow at the Thomas B. Fordham Institute. She blogs at Good School Hunting and occasionally writes for other outlets including Scary Mommy, The 74, and The Hill. She is the mother of three school aged sons who currently attend a district school, a charter school, and a private school—in 3 different zip codes! Rhode Island is home.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Recent Posts

Video Chat: Two Moms Offer Tips for Parents Who Need to Get Their Own Work Done with Kids Home All the Time

It is clear from reading the newspaper or scrolling through social media that many parents are exasperated by feeling like they can't...

In Wake of COVID-19, Teacher Unions Could Learn From Rhode Island

If you had asked me a few weeks ago if I'd be publicly lauding the teachers' unions in my state of Rhode...

Football Coach’s Wisdom Can Serve Educators Well During COVID-19 Crisis

Bob Sullivan, the head coach of my college football team a zillion years ago (and one of the most important people in my life),...

How Isaac Newton Turned Isolation From the Great Plague Into a “Year of Wonders”

College students around the world left campus this month, unsure when they would return and what daily life would look like until...

How We Teachers Handle the COVID-19 Crisis Will Leave a Lasting Impact

There is nothing I love more than walking into my classroom every morning to a room of empty desks, knowing they will...